and damagin psychiatry and is toxic to the profession and i am against that self destructive influence from inside psychiatry so i am actually pro psychiatry and i am anti the current pro psychiatry which is actually antipsychiatry if you can see how it is so twisted around right but i dont know if that makes it cleat but that is basically my position on it.
Yes we have talked about in other videos i am critical from the pespective of what is it that is actually biologically medically sicentifically true here and what has been put forth by biological psychiatry just isn not scientifically true it is no a scientific fact that these are medical diseases. It is not a sientific fact that we have identified genes or set of genes tat cause especific psychiatric disorders. It is not true that medications are powerful and effective. It is not true that there is identified chemical imbalances these thing simply are not scientifically true so the probem is when you make this kind of commentary yo can very easily get put in the box of being an antipsychiatrist so antipsychiatry is just kind of a box, that is used to dismiss people who are critical of the field there is not actually any organized antipsychiatry movement so it is not really a thing that even exists is just kind of a little chess move in a game and certainly.anytime you have a whatever it might be in this case psychiatry we have a field and there are people with and there are people with skepticism about the claims made by certain proffessionals in that fied theres is goint to be a certain you know and hominem attack anybody who is making those criticismis and i think what you describe about Thomas saws is very was a perfect example because here everything you were told about him of he is a friend he is a lunatic he is this crazy gay not even worth looking at anything he said and you ended up actually going and reading the book yourself and seeing that none of those things are true that was just an attack on this guy and in no way refuted the information that he had put forth in that in that book exactly.
So if it is just this perhaps certain aspects of psychiatry that you are critical of your skeptical of can you kind of pinpoint you know where that is coming from or where those certain claims are rooted perhaps .